A simple head turn can vastly improve understanding of speech in noisy enviroments
Listeners in a noisy situation benefit from facing slightly away from the person they are listening to, turning one ear towards the speech, concludes a study by Cardiff University, funded by UK charity Action on Hearing Loss (RNID).
This listening tactic was found to be especially beneficial for cochlear implant users who typically struggle in noisy social settings such as restaurants. It was also found to be compatible with lip reading which was unaffected by a modest, 30-degree head orientation, illustrating that the benefits of lip-reading and turning an ear towards a talker can be combined.
Dr Jacques Grange from Cardiff University’s School of Psychology said: “Noise can be a big issue for any listener and especially for someone with a cochlear implant. Our study shows that by simply turning one ear towards the person they are listening to, cochlear implant users find it much easier to hear that person above background noise, enabling them to engage in conversations in noisy environments, and not become isolated. It’s better to have a clear signal in one ear than a mediocre signal in both.”
When tested in the laboratory, with the speech in front of the listener and interfering noise behind, the technique resulted in a 4-decibel improvement to intelligibility of speech in a noisy environment for both normal-hearing listeners and cochlear implant users. A 4-decibel improvement can be the difference between understanding nothing and perfect understanding.
Dr Ralph Holme, Head of Biomedical Research at Action on Hearing Loss said: “Action on Hearing Loss is delighted to have funded this important study which has highlighted a simple, yet effective tactic that everyone can use to help hear friends and family in noisy places such as restaurants and hopefully this advice can be relayed to cochlear implant users who would really stand to benefit. We are also campaigning for bars, restaurants and cafes to do more to improve their acoustics to make it easier for people with a hearing loss to engage in conversation.”
To simulate a realistic restaurant listening situation, acoustic measurements were also taken in the Mezza Luna restaurant in Cardiff and used to create a virtual acoustic simulation. In the simulation normally hearing listeners were tested at each table with three different head orientations: facing the target talker, with a 30-degree head turn to the left, or with a 30-degree head turn to the right. The data showed that a significant head-orientation benefit still occurred with this high level of realism. The two experiments allow for conclusions to be made about the causal effect of head turning on the understanding of speech in both a laboratory and a real-world setting.
The paper ‘Head orientation benefit to speech intelligibility in noise for cochlear implant users and in realistic listening conditions’ is published in the Journal of the Acoustical Society of America.